adapted by Eric Shanower
illustrated by Skottie Young
216 pages / 2010
Some classics, even with specifically unChristian elements, are still worth reading for the sake of cultural literacy. Examples would include the Greek myths, George Orwell's 1984, and Niccolò Machiavelli's The Prince. Frank Baum's The Wizard of Oz is another of this sort, a book so famous that is has spawned multiple plays, many films, near countless books, and now a series of graphic novels.
Marvel Comic's adaptation is faithfully done, and large enough to include all of the key plot points. Here's how it begins: Dorothy, a girl from Kansas, gets picked up, while inside her house, by a tornado and dropped, house and all, in a very strange land and on top of a very wicked witch. Then she is off to see an oh-so-wonderful wizard to find out if he can help her get back to Kansas.
As she sets off towards the interior of this strange land – the land of Oz – she picks up three strange companions on her way: a talking scarecrow in want of a brain, a tin woodsman wishing for a heart, and a enormous lion who desires courage. When she finally gets to meet the Wizard of Oz, he says he will only help her and her friends if Dorothy kills Oz's only other wicked witch (Dorothy did in the first when her house landed on the evil creature).
That's the gist of the story. The fun of it is that her three companions – brainless scarecrow, heartless tin woodsman, and cowardly lion – all want the wizard to help them get what they lack. But along the way we learn that, despite what the three think themselves, they really aren't lacking in those departments at all.
The problems with the story, from a Christian perspective are:
- Not all the witches in it are bad. The land has two wicked witches, but also two good witches, one of which plays a major role. That conflicts quite directly with God's condemnation of witchcraft.
- Second, the heroes all find what they need is inside themselves already. This, on the one hand, is no big deal. It is a good lesson for all of us to learn that courage is not "not being afraid" but rather being afraid and acting anyway, and while the cowardly lion never learns this, we do, by watching just how brave this coward can be.
Similarly we also learn from the woodsman that it is not the having of a heart that gives us compassion, but acting compassionately that shows compassion. It is the act, and not even the feeling (which the woodsman also has) that is key, and certainly not the having of a heart.
The Scarecrow gets his brains via the insertion of some sharp tacks where he previous had only hay but he has shown his ability to think long before. (Here the movie version does things better. The Scarecrow is told brains are overrated, and that many a graduate finishes school without one, but that they have one thing that he doesn't: a diploma, which the Wizard then gives him.)
But the fact that these three companions, turn out to already have the very thing they've most been seeking, and it's already inside themselves, is also an example of humanistic "all I need is me" self-worship.
While I think this a classic worth reading for cultural literacy's sake, I would fully understand why parents might not want to read this book to their children or have them read it. Still this is an American classic and from the perspective of having a cultural awareness there is a reason to read it. Then the cautions to consider are only that some scenes might be a bit scary for the very young. I'd suggest this for 7 and up.
(Puffin books came out with their own adaption by Michael Cavallaro which isn't bad, but isn't nearly as good as the Marvel version. The Puffin version is black and white, smaller at just 5.5 by 8 inches, shorter at 148 pages, and there is one scene, featuring the Scarecrow taking on crows, which makes far less sense in the Puffin book – the Scarecrow suddenly has the mysteriously acquired ability to grow into a giant.)
So, if you object to the original Frank Baum novel, you shouldn't get this graphic novel version. But if you want a quicker way to work through the book, this graphic novel might well be more interesting than the novel for readers both young and old.
You can buy a copy at Amazon.com by clicking here.
Thank you! I agree with your comments on this book. My kids and I thoroughly enjoyed Narnia, had some questions about the book Mary Poppins, and were just having a discussion about the Wizard of Oz series with its "good" witches. There is an excellent book (seemingly from a Reformed perspective) on the subject of fantasy called "A Landscape with Dragaons" by O'Brien. I had been sharing favourite authors and books for the younger crowd at abcbookreviews.wordpress.com but am grateful for suggestions for the teen years as the kids get older!ReplyDelete